DIY Pest Solutions » Rodent Control » Do Mouse Traps Kill Mice?

Do Mouse Traps Kill Mice?


Cerceris Is Supported By Our Readers Through Affiliate Links

All our content is created independently and never Sponsored. We only recommend products and deals based on our own research and requests from you, our readers.

If you buy a product that we recommend via one of the links on this site, we may get a commission from the company the link points to.  If you decide to return that product for whatever reason, we make nothing.

That means there’s no incentive for us to try to convince you to buy a specific product - the reality is the opposite.  We need you to make the right decision first time so we can continue to provide future guides and advice.

Pest control is an important aspect of home maintenance.

One of the most common and troublesome pests that homeowners often find themselves dealing with are mice.

Mice are hard to control and get rid of because once there is one mouse inside a home, there tend to be more hiding.

Choosing the best mouse traps and successfully catching your first rodent does not end the hunt; in fact after catching a few mice, it is advisable to continue setting and baiting your traps on an ongoing basis and the only way to guarantee that they are all gone.

There is a struggle often encountered by homeowners trying to control mice and rodents infesting their homes. They tend to ask, do mouse traps kill mice? Is it necessary to kill them or are there alternatives? These are common and understandable questions to ask. After all, not everyone is comfortable injuring or killing a rodent, even if they are considered as pests.

Luckily for homeowners there are now varieties of mousetraps available. Choosing one which matches your comfort level will help you deal with the mouse problem at home more effectively and sooner.

Pros and cons of kill traps

As the name “kill trap” suggests, this type of mousetrap is used to catch and kill or seriously injure mice. If you are not comfortable reading about these forms of traps, skip to the next section where humane traps will be discussed.

The pros

Kill traps provide a more permanent solution. A mouse is trapped, killed, and disposed of, so it eliminates the worry of mice coming back to your home. Classic snap traps are also very cheap and affordable. For those who do not want the fuss and mess of cleaning up, they have the option of throwing out the cheap spring snapping trap and setting a new one without breaking their budget.

There are also a number of different kill trap options such as: the classic spring trap, the high-tech electrocuting trap, poisoned trap boxed, and glue traps. These have been proven effective in catching, trapping, and eliminating mice. Most of them are also reusable for those who want to save a few bucks while still effectively getting rid of their rodent problem.

The cons

The biggest con of kill traps is that they kill mice and not everyone approves of this pest-eliminating method. Killing mice also comes with a lot of bacteria, fecal matter, and blood on floors or other surfaces. Homeowners who use spring snap traps need to be extra attentive when cleaning the traps if they plan to reuse it to ensure that it is thoroughly cleaned. The area where the mouse was killed also needs special cleaning attention because it may also have a lot of blood and bacteria.

Kill traps like ones that use poison or electrocution aren’t that messy, but cleaning the traps is also a must, just to maintain good hygiene. Glue traps are perhaps the messiest and inhumane form of kill trap. Not everyone approves of this form of mousetrap, even if it is very effective.

Pros and cons of humane mousetraps

Killing mice isn’t the only way to control the infestation at home. There are many homeowners who prefer to use humane mousetraps to handle their mouse problem and they are just as effective as kill traps, but they also have their pros and cons.

The pros

First of all, humane mouse traps do not kill, they trap mice. Humane traps are usually plastic or metal boxes that have a trigger door that closes when a mouse is inside.

They keep the rodent securely contained until it is time to release them. Humane mouse traps are also safer to use than traditional kill traps because they do not pose any significant danger to pets or small children.  Live cages are also available in different sizes for trapping nuisance animals, regardless of species.

The cons

Humane mouse traps require a bit of cleaning as well.  Although no messy cleanup involving blood and guts is required, mice are still dirty and a trap still needs cleaning once in a while. And you are responsible for the release of the trapped rodents in areas where they cannot enter another person’s home. This is tricky, especially when you live in crowded areas.


Do mouse traps kill mice? Not all do. When it comes to rodent management, working with traps that you are comfortable with is the key to success. If you don’t mind the extra effort, humane traps are just as effective as kill traps.



How Does a Mousetrap Work?


What to Put on a Mousetrap


How to Bait a Mouse Trap


Best Way to Get Rid of Mice


Using a Mouse Trap: A Guide for First-Time Users

humane mouse trap release rodent

The Best Humane Mouse Trap


Can You Reuse a Mouse Trap?

Links & Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Cerceris May Get A Commission. Last updated on 2020-08-21


Kat Sense Rat Trap Pack

Rat Zapper Classic Rat Trap

Eliminator Electronic Rat and Rodent Trap

SavHome Rat Trap

Woodstream 1079 32-Inch Live Animal Cage

AB Traps Live Humane Cage

Pestrax Electronic Mouse Trap

Trapper Pack by Kraftex

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.